Aeration Story - Worth It or Not?

I just got done scalping the lawn and cleaning up the thatch. Now I’m trying to figure out how to rent an aerator from Home Depot. It says $77 for 4 hours, but I’ll probably need a trailer or some ramps too… What a hassle. I’ll likely end up spending a few hours getting all this done.

While driving, I saw a yard sign for lawn aeration and texted the number to get a quote. They quoted me $60! They came by today with a big trailer and used a professional Ryan aerator. They were done in 20 minutes and my lawn is about 7500 sq ft.

I’m glad I texted that number instead of going through the trouble myself. Now I just need to add topsoil and seed this weekend.

Dethatching has become more popular lately, especially because of YouTube channels and other similar sources. But there’s a lot of misinformation about it.

Thatch is a layer of roots and stems (both living and dead) that sits on top of the soil. Grass clippings aren’t thatch and don’t cause thatch buildup. You can only know how much thatch you have by digging into the soil.

Having some thatch is good. While different sources have various opinions, most agree that having less than an inch is fine. Thatch helps prevent weeds, deals with foot traffic, and keeps moisture, so removing it isn’t always needed. Too much thatch can be a sign of other issues like overwatering, over-fertilizing, or using too many chemicals.

Using tools like Sunjoe dethatchers can damage your lawn in the short and long term, and they can cause some weeds to spread. A better option for thatch issues is core aeration, which helps break it down naturally without hurting the grass. Other options include using scarifiers or verticutters, which cause less damage.

For overseeding, better choices are slit seeding, scarifying, or using manual rakes. If you want more details on seeding, check out our seeding guide.

Where are you located?

Val said:
Where are you located?

Exactly! Especially since your username isn’t giving it away :grin:

Val said:
Where are you located?

I’m in the St. Louis area.

Fable said:

Val said:
Where are you located?

I’m in the St. Louis area.

Which part? Please tell me you’re on the Illinois side.

Fable said:

Val said:
Where are you located?

I’m in the St. Louis area.

Just sent you a DM for that number. I’m in St. Louis County.

Fable said:

Val said:
Where are you located?

I’m in the St. Louis area.

The Home Depot on Hanley has an aerator that fits in the back of a CX-5. I know from experience :smile:

Good deal. I usually charge $80 for aeration.

Drew said:
Good deal. I usually charge $80 for aeration.

Where are you located? I can’t find anyone around here doing it for that price.

Dru said:

Drew said:
Good deal. I usually charge $80 for aeration.

Where are you located? I can’t find anyone around here doing it for that price.

Same here. I can’t get anyone to do it for less than $400 where I am.

I wish people in my area offered those services! Those machines are way better than any of the rentals. They pull out clean plugs.

Same. Someone in my local lawn care group gave me a number for a guy who does aeration, so I reached out. I ended up paying the same amount I’d spend to rent a machine myself.

Wow, that’s a good deal you got!

Tal said:
Wow, that’s a good deal you got!

Hold on, you’re charging $540 an hour?

Dell said:

Tal said:
Wow, that’s a good deal you got!

Hold on, you’re charging $540 an hour?

Who said I bill by the hour? :wink:

I paid $100 here, and I think it’s totally worth it.

Arden said:
I paid $100 here, and I think it’s totally worth it.

Where are you at? I’m struggling to find anyone who charges close to that around here.

I paid $80 too. If someone will do it for the same cost as renting, it’s a no-brainer!

Skylar said:
I paid $80 too. If someone will do it for the same cost as renting, it’s a no-brainer!

Where are you located? No luck finding a similar price here.